Ohio Workforce Supply-Demand Gap Analysis
  • Statewide Overview
  • Career Cluster Analysis
  • Cross-Cluster Analysis
  • Summary of Findings
  • Methodology

Career Cluster Analysis

This section presents supply-demand conditions for each of Ohio’s 14 Career Clusters. Each cluster follows a standardized format: a snapshot table of key workforce and education metrics, a combined Sub-Cluster gap and institution type exhibit, a supply gap and demand-supply ratio exhibit by education level, and tables of top-producing institutions and programs. Sub-cluster names reflect the Advance CTE framework as implemented in the Ohio LMI crosswalk. Because occupations can map to multiple Sub-Clusters and Career Clusters are not mutually exclusive, gap figures within and across clusters should be interpreted as directional indicators of relative workforce pressure rather than additive totals.

Advanced Manufacturing

Advanced Manufacturing encompasses Ohio’s industrial production base, spanning precision engineering and robotics, quality assurance, industrial maintenance, and welding and fabrication. Ohio is among the top manufacturing states nationally; the cluster generates sustained demand across both sub-baccalaureate and bachelor’s-level pathways, with the bulk of openings concentrated in production and automation roles. The Sub-Cluster exhibit below identifies where within the cluster the gap is most acute; the institution type display shows which sectors currently supply the workforce.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Engineering; Industrial Machinery; Production & Automation; Robotics; Safety & Quality Assurance
Adj. Graduates 6,701
Conversion Rate 14.8%
Annual Supply Gap 6,882
Proj. Annual Growth 483
Total Employment 381,782
Total Earnings $26.3B
Avg Earnings/Worker $68,800
D-S Ratio 2.03
Table 1: Advanced Manufacturing: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Advanced Manufacturing. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 1: Advanced Manufacturing: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Advanced Manufacturing adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 2: Advanced Manufacturing: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Advanced Manufacturing: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 3: Advanced Manufacturing: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,693 38.8% 598 14.8%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 1,491 70.0% 558 13.8%
Stark State College Public 2-Year 960 70.6% 492 12.2%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,696 54.5% 484 12.0%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 807 66.6% 403 10.0%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 1,596 47.2% 346 8.6%
Edison State Community College Public 2-Year 491 79.8% 331 8.2%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,107 51.7% 305 7.6%
University of Toledo Public 4-Year 819 52.7% 257 6.4%
University of Dayton Private NFP 4-Year 817 46.5% 255 6.3%
Table 2: Advanced Manufacturing: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 15.0399 Electrical/Electronic Engineering Technologies/Technicians, Other Associate's degree 1,643 25.8% 8 1
2 14.1901 Mechanical Engineering Associate's degree 945 14.8% 17 3
3 15.0403 Electromechanical/Electromechanical Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 766 12.0% 11 2
4 15.0805 Mechanical/Mechanical Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 677 10.6% 23 3
5 15.0303 Electrical, Electronic, and Communications Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 628 9.9% 19 6
6 15.0613 Manufacturing Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 535 8.4% 15 1
7 14.0701 Chemical Engineering Bachelor's degree 346 5.4% 11 2
8 14.1001 Electrical and Electronics Engineering Bachelor's degree 343 5.4% 16 3
9 14.0501 Bioengineering and Biomedical Engineering Bachelor's degree 246 3.9% 10 2
10 15.0614 Welding Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 236 3.7% 3 2
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 3: Advanced Manufacturing: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Agriculture

Agriculture includes agribusiness, agricultural technology and automation, animal systems, conservation and land management, food processing and distribution, and plant systems. This cluster has a low conversion rate, meaning postsecondary programs cover only a limited share of total occupational openings; many roles in this sector are filled through on-the-job pathways rather than formal higher education credentials. The measured supply gap reflects unmet demand within the postsecondary-aligned portion of the cluster. The demand-supply ratio should be interpreted with caution and weighed against the absolute gap rather than used as a primary severity indicator.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Agribusiness; Agricultural Technology & Automation; Animal Systems; Food Science & Processing; Plant Systems; Water Systems
Adj. Graduates 661
Conversion Rate 4.9%
Annual Supply Gap 244
Proj. Annual Growth 118
Total Employment 21,274
Total Earnings $1.3B
Avg Earnings/Worker $62,600
D-S Ratio 1.371
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 4: Agriculture: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Agriculture. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 4: Agriculture: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Agriculture adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 5: Agriculture: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Agriculture: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 6: Agriculture: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,635 42.6% 245 48.1%
Ohio State University Agricultural Technical Institute Public 4-Year 126 64.6% 67 13.2%
The University of Findlay Private NFP 4-Year 93 53.7% 44 8.6%
Wilmington College Private NFP 4-Year 73 53.3% 38 7.4%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 57 82.3% 37 7.3%
Hocking College Public 2-Year 62 46.1% 20 3.9%
Valley College-Cleveland Private FP 2-Year 47 36.5% 16 3.2%
University of Cincinnati-Blue Ash College Public 4-Year 69 48.6% 15 2.9%
Kent State University at Tuscarawas Public 4-Year 29 66.3% 15 2.9%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 108 18.3% 12 2.4%
Table 5: Agriculture: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 01.0901 Animal Sciences, General Associate's degree 123 27.2% 2 3
2 01.8301 Veterinary/Animal Health Technology/Technician and Veterinary Assistant Associate's degree 100 22.1% 8 2
3 01.0101 Agricultural Business and Management, General Associate's degree 51 11.3% 6 1
4 01.0507 Equestrian/Equine Studies Associate's degree 36 8.0% 4 1
5 01.8001 Veterinary Medicine Doctor's or Professional 31 6.9% 1 1
6 01.0103 Agricultural Economics Bachelor's degree 31 6.8% 2 1
7 26.0802 Molecular Genetics Bachelor's degree 22 4.9% 1 1
8 01.1101 Plant Sciences, General Bachelor's degree 21 4.6% 1 3
9 01.1001 Food Science Bachelor's degree 20 4.4% 1 2
10 40.0601 Geology/Earth Science, General Bachelor's degree 17 3.8% 20 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 6: Agriculture: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Arts, Entertainment, & Design

Arts, Entertainment, & Design spans design and digital arts, film and broadcast, interactive media, journalism and communications, performing arts, and visual arts. Graduate supply in this cluster is relatively close to demand in several Sub-Clusters, but the design and digital arts pathway shows a persistent gap driven in part by demand from technology-adjacent industries. The cluster carries a meaningful absolute gap of 7,316 and a modest total earnings footprint relative to other undersupplied clusters; program targeting in this space should account for the degree to which design graduates serve adjacent technology and media sectors beyond the cluster’s direct occupational definition. In the Advance CTE framework mapping, the design & digital arts Sub-Cluster pulls in technology-adjacent occupations (graphic designers, multimedia artists, web developers, producers) that carry substantially higher wages than performing arts or fine arts roles. Because the framework maps these occupations into the Arts cluster, the average is anchored upward by those higher-wage design and media-tech roles.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Design & Digital Arts; Fashion & Interiors; Fine Arts; Lighting & Sound Technology; Media Production & Broadcasting; Performing Arts
Adj. Graduates 3,051
Conversion Rate 13.6%
Annual Supply Gap 7,316
Proj. Annual Growth 1,096
Total Employment 143,043
Total Earnings $13B
Avg Earnings/Worker $90,800
D-S Ratio 3.40
Table 7: Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Arts, Entertainment, & Design. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 7: Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Arts, Entertainment, & Design adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 8: Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 9: Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,312 45.3% 365 19.7%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,069 41.2% 252 13.6%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 863 52.9% 229 12.4%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,257 54.7% 228 12.3%
Bowling Green State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 695 46.8% 201 10.9%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 648 48.4% 178 9.6%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 567 34.2% 146 7.9%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 342 53.8% 89 4.8%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 224 58.0% 82 4.4%
Oberlin College Private NFP 4-Year 278 42.5% 81 4.4%
Table 8: Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 31.0504 Sport and Fitness Administration/Management Associate's degree 401 24.8% 43 1
2 09.0702 Digital Communication and Media/Multimedia Associate's degree 195 12.1% 15 2
3 11.0201 Computer Programming/Programmer, General Associate's degree 181 11.2% 11 2
4 09.0101 Speech Communication and Rhetoric Associate's degree 167 10.3% 29 2
5 50.0903 Music Performance, General Bachelor's degree 144 8.9% 23 2
6 09.0401 Journalism Bachelor's degree 144 8.9% 12 4
7 09.0701 Radio and Television Associate's degree 109 6.8% 6 4
8 50.0101 Visual and Performing Arts, General Bachelor's degree 107 6.6% 6 3
9 23.1302 Creative Writing Associate's degree 86 5.3% 17 2
10 50.0402 Commercial and Advertising Art Associate's degree 82 5.0% 7 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 9: Arts, Entertainment, & Design: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Construction

Construction includes architecture and civil engineering, construction management, construction planning and development, and skilled trades. Demand is concentrated in sub-baccalaureate pathways, reflecting the skilled-trades composition of the sector; two-year institutions and certificate programs are the primary supply channel for most construction occupations. This concentration means that changes in associate and certificate program capacity have an outsized effect on the cluster’s supply-demand balance relative to four-year program expansion. The supply gap by education level exhibit shows a very large demand-supply ratio at the doctoral/doctor’s or professional level; this reflects a methodological artifact rather than a genuine workforce signal. A small share of workers in managerial and supervisory construction occupations hold doctoral/doctor’s degrees, and O*NET assigns a correspondingly small but non-zero weight to those occupations at that credential level. Because essentially no Ohio graduates are routed to construction occupations through doctoral/doctor’s programs as currently defined, the resulting ratio appears extreme but carries no policy interpretation. Note how small the total supply and demand bars are on the left bar chart.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Architecture & Civil Engineering; Construction Planning & Development; Equipment Operation & Maintenance; Skilled Trades
Adj. Graduates 2,614
Conversion Rate 9.0%
Annual Supply Gap 11,722
Proj. Annual Growth 448
Total Employment 332,056
Total Earnings $22.9B
Avg Earnings/Worker $68,900
D-S Ratio 5.481
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 10: Construction: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Construction. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 10: Construction: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Construction adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 11: Construction: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Construction: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 12: Construction: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 844 80.0% 416 24.7%
Stark State College Public 2-Year 581 73.7% 305 18.1%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 706 51.6% 172 10.2%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 832 56.4% 165 9.8%
Owens Community College Public 2-Year 352 66.2% 136 8.1%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 576 56.0% 129 7.6%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 1,177 47.8% 121 7.2%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 224 72.2% 91 5.4%
Lorain County Community College Public 2-Year 491 48.0% 85 5.0%
Cleveland State University Public 4-Year 429 70.4% 66 3.9%
Table 11: Construction: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 52.0201 Business Administration and Management, General Associate's degree 419 19.1% 55 2
2 14.0801 Civil Engineering, General Bachelor's degree 332 15.1% 12 2
3 48.0508 Welding Technology/Welder Associate's degree 322 14.6% 19 2
4 15.0614 Welding Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 236 10.7% 3 2
5 46.0503 Plumbing Technology/Plumber Associate's degree 201 9.1% 3 2
6 47.0201 Heating, Air Conditioning, Ventilation and Refrigeration Maintenance Technology/Technician Associate's degree 182 8.3% 11 1
7 15.1001 Construction Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 180 8.2% 10 2
8 04.0201 Architecture Bachelor's degree 123 5.6% 4 2
9 52.0205 Operations Management and Supervision Associate's degree 106 4.8% 10 2
10 15.0501 Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 98 4.5% 9 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 12: Construction: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Digital Technology

Digital Technology covers cybersecurity, data science and artificial intelligence, IT infrastructure, software and web development, and technology management. This cluster carries a comparatively modest absolute supply gap of 3,219 but combines that gap with the second-fastest projected annual growth among all 14 clusters (1,633 net new positions). In addition, the cluster has the highest average earnings per worker in the state at approximately $102,500, barely above Energy & Natural Resources at $101,200. The combination of strong forward-looking demand and high wage levels places Digital Technology among clusters with the strongest economic returns to closing the gap, even where the absolute gap ranks below most other clusters. The Software Solutions, Web & Cloud, and Network Systems & Cybersecurity Sub-Clusters drive most of the unmet demand, and the cluster draws graduates from a relatively broad set of institution types.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Data Science & AI; IT Support & Services; Network Systems & Cybersecurity; Software Solutions; Web & Cloud
Adj. Graduates 7,693
Conversion Rate 9.0%
Annual Supply Gap 3,219
Proj. Annual Growth 1,633
Total Employment 170,393
Total Earnings $17.5B
Avg Earnings/Worker $102,500
D-S Ratio 1.421
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 13: Digital Technology: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Digital Technology. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 13: Digital Technology: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Digital Technology adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 14: Digital Technology: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Digital Technology: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 15: Digital Technology: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
MyComputerCareer at Columbus Private FP 2-Year 3,134 58.8% 1,844 34.3%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,103 69.3% 957 17.8%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 868 66.8% 552 10.3%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,069 42.7% 394 7.3%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 671 66.8% 388 7.2%
Stark State College Public 2-Year 522 60.1% 301 5.6%
Lakeland Community College Public 2-Year 416 60.9% 253 4.7%
Cuyahoga Community College District Public 2-Year 482 58.2% 244 4.5%
Cleveland State University Public 4-Year 665 46.9% 238 4.4%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 750 54.8% 208 3.9%
Table 14: Digital Technology: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 11.0901 Computer Systems Networking and Telecommunications Associate's degree 1,494 24.0% 12 5
2 11.1003 Computer and Information Systems Security/Auditing/Information Assurance Associate's degree 940 15.1% 15 7
3 11.0101 Computer and Information Sciences, General Associate's degree 882 14.2% 19 10
4 11.0701 Computer Science Associate's degree 728 11.7% 32 12
5 11.0103 Information Technology Associate's degree 536 8.6% 11 9
6 11.0401 Information Science/Studies Associate's degree 433 7.0% 6 6
7 14.0901 Computer Engineering, General Bachelor's degree 404 6.5% 15 5
8 11.0201 Computer Programming/Programmer, General Associate's degree 370 5.9% 11 6
9 11.0202 Computer Programming, Specific Applications Associate's degree 253 4.1% 15 3
10 52.1201 Management Information Systems, General Associate's degree 188 3.0% 14 3
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 15: Digital Technology: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Education

Education encompasses early childhood development, education support services, health data and administration, and teaching and instruction. Ohio faces persistent shortages in teaching and instruction pathways, with demand driven by both replacement needs in K–12 and postsecondary settings and by ongoing enrollment growth in early childhood contexts. Public four-year institutions supply most graduates in this cluster. The health data and administration Sub-Cluster, while smaller in absolute terms, draws graduates from a mix of institution types and reflects growing demand at the intersection of education and health informatics.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Early Childhood Development; Education Administration & Leadership; Learner Support & Community Engagement; Teaching, Training, & Facilitation
Adj. Graduates 21,197
Conversion Rate 16.3%
Annual Supply Gap 3,411
Proj. Annual Growth 1,026
Total Employment 351,464
Total Earnings $24.4B
Avg Earnings/Worker $69,500
D-S Ratio 1.16
Table 16: Education: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Education. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 16: Education: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Education adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 17: Education: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Education: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 18: Education: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 12,566 48.3% 1,922 18.4%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 9,143 54.4% 1,395 13.4%
Cuyahoga Community College District Public 2-Year 2,726 61.8% 1,239 11.9%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 4,624 57.9% 1,106 10.6%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 6,139 55.5% 930 8.9%
Bowling Green State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 3,180 58.5% 895 8.6%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 2,140 56.9% 864 8.3%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 2,606 48.7% 767 7.4%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 4,179 42.9% 667 6.4%
Cleveland State University Public 4-Year 3,308 63.9% 648 6.2%
Table 17: Education: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 24.0101 Liberal Arts and Sciences/Liberal Studies Associate's degree 3,511 35.7% 33 1
2 24.0102 General Studies Associate's degree 1,310 13.3% 36 1
3 26.0101 Biology/Biological Sciences, General Associate's degree 962 9.8% 55 2
4 13.1001 Special Education and Teaching, General Associate's degree 896 9.1% 29 4
5 13.1210 Early Childhood Education and Teaching Associate's degree 648 6.6% 36 4
6 51.1501 Substance Abuse/Addiction Counseling Associate's degree 540 5.5% 13 1
7 13.0101 Education, General Bachelor's degree 534 5.4% 21 1
8 44.0701 Social Work Associate's degree 513 5.2% 39 2
9 23.0101 English Language and Literature, General Associate's degree 462 4.7% 52 2
10 45.1001 Political Science and Government, General Associate's degree 461 4.7% 45 2
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 18: Education: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Energy & Natural Resources

Energy & Natural Resources includes clean and alternative energy, energy infrastructure, environmental services, mining and extraction, natural resources management, and utilities. Like Agriculture, this cluster has a low conversion rate; postsecondary programs account for a limited share of total occupational openings, and the demand-supply ratio is therefore less interpretable as a severity measure than the absolute gap. The gap that does exist is concentrated in infrastructure and environmental services roles, occupations where credential-based pathways are growing in relevance as the sector transitions toward clean energy and updated utility infrastructure.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Clean & Alternative Energy; Conservation & Land Management; Ecological Research & Development; Environmental Protection; Resource Extraction; Utilities
Adj. Graduates 925
Conversion Rate 7.5%
Annual Supply Gap 6,850
Proj. Annual Growth 270
Total Employment 253,457
Total Earnings $25.6B
Avg Earnings/Worker $101,200
D-S Ratio 8.411
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 19: Energy & Natural Resources: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Energy & Natural Resources. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 19: Energy & Natural Resources: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Energy & Natural Resources adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 20: Energy & Natural Resources: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Energy & Natural Resources: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 21: Energy & Natural Resources: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,600 40.0% 252 30.2%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 352 86.8% 140 16.7%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,040 47.3% 137 16.5%
Stark State College Public 2-Year 132 68.4% 54 6.4%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 626 33.2% 50 5.9%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 298 52.7% 47 5.6%
Owens Community College Public 2-Year 93 72.8% 42 5.0%
Hocking College Public 2-Year 96 54.0% 39 4.7%
University of Dayton Private NFP 4-Year 333 42.5% 37 4.5%
Cincinnati State Technical and Community College Public 2-Year 72 63.5% 37 4.4%
Table 20: Energy & Natural Resources: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 40.0601 Geology/Earth Science, General Associate's degree 143 17.6% 20 4
2 15.1102 Surveying Technology/Surveying Associate's degree 123 15.1% 5 2
3 14.1001 Electrical and Electronics Engineering Bachelor's degree 96 11.9% 16 1
4 46.0503 Plumbing Technology/Plumber Associate's degree 96 11.8% 3 2
5 15.0612 Industrial Technology/Technician Associate's degree 88 10.9% 8 1
6 26.0202 Biochemistry Associate's degree 64 7.9% 27 1
7 15.0201 Civil Engineering Technologies/Technicians Associate's degree 53 6.5% 9 1
8 03.0104 Environmental Science Associate's degree 50 6.2% 28 3
9 26.9999 Biological and Biomedical Sciences, Other Associate's degree 49 6.0% 4 1
10 14.1401 Environmental/Environmental Health Engineering Associate's degree 49 6.0% 7 2
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 21: Energy & Natural Resources: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Financial Services

Financial Services covers accounting, banking and credit, financial planning, insurance, and investment services. Demand concentrates at the bachelor’s level, reflecting the credential expectations of the sector’s core professional roles, with secondary demand at the associate and certificate levels in insurance operations and banking services. Ohio’s large financial services sector generates stable replacement demand alongside moderate projected growth. Total earnings in this cluster ($21.3B) reflect a relatively high wage profile relative to the number of openings, making gap-filling in this cluster economically meaningful on a per-position basis.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Accounting; Banking & Credit; Financial Strategy & Investments; Insurance; Real Estate
Adj. Graduates 3,979
Conversion Rate 7.7%
Annual Supply Gap 9,936
Proj. Annual Growth 576
Total Employment 302,132
Total Earnings $21.3B
Avg Earnings/Worker $70,500
D-S Ratio 3.501
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 22: Financial Services: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Financial Services. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 22: Financial Services: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Financial Services adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 23: Financial Services: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Financial Services: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 24: Financial Services: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,569 48.4% 441 20.8%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,357 64.3% 292 13.8%
Lorain County Community College Public 2-Year 470 63.9% 281 13.3%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 456 66.4% 263 12.4%
Stark State College Public 2-Year 279 63.8% 174 8.2%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 1,233 37.7% 165 7.8%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 572 28.7% 152 7.2%
Franklin University Private NFP 4-Year 797 58.5% 121 5.7%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 968 60.8% 117 5.5%
Cleveland State University Public 4-Year 464 74.7% 115 5.4%
Table 23: Financial Services: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 52.0301 Accounting Associate's degree 1,496 40.5% 47 5
2 52.1501 Real Estate Associate's degree 855 23.1% 14 3
3 52.0801 Finance, General Associate's degree 600 16.2% 35 7
4 52.0302 Accounting Technology/Technician and Bookkeeping Associate's degree 352 9.5% 20 3
5 52.1601 Taxation Associate's degree 101 2.7% 2 3
6 52.1001 Human Resources Management/Personnel Administration, General Associate's degree 90 2.4% 22 2
7 19.0401 Family Resource Management Studies, General Bachelor's degree 71 1.9% 1 1
8 22.0302 Legal Assistant/Paralegal Associate's degree 47 1.3% 15 1
9 52.1701 Insurance Associate's degree 43 1.2% 6 5
10 27.0305 Financial Mathematics Bachelor's degree 42 1.1% 4 3
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 24: Financial Services: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Healthcare & Human Services

Healthcare & Human Services encompasses behavioral and mental health, community and social services, diagnostic services, health informatics, nursing and patient care, and therapeutic services. This cluster carries one of the largest absolute supply gaps in the state, with a gap of 16,325 and the fastest projected annual employment growth among all 14 clusters (2,876 net new positions). The Physical Health and Behavioral & Mental Health Sub-Clusters drive most of the unmet demand. The gap spans all credential levels, reflecting Ohio’s broad healthcare workforce challenges, but associate-level programs are a particularly critical supply channel given the occupational composition of the nursing and allied health pipeline.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Behavioral & Mental Health; Biotechnology Research & Development; Community & Social Services; Health Data & Administration; Personal Care Services; Physical Health
Adj. Graduates 23,415
Conversion Rate 21.8%
Annual Supply Gap 16,325
Proj. Annual Growth 2,876
Total Employment 677,342
Total Earnings $50.9B
Avg Earnings/Worker $75,100
D-S Ratio 1.70
Table 25: Healthcare & Human Services: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Healthcare & Human Services. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 25: Healthcare & Human Services: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Healthcare & Human Services adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 26: Healthcare & Human Services: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Healthcare & Human Services: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 27: Healthcare & Human Services: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 3,918 61.7% 1,665 17.5%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 5,788 57.5% 1,538 16.2%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 4,171 50.1% 1,071 11.3%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 1,572 68.0% 929 9.8%
Hondros College of Nursing Private FP 2-Year 1,287 68.7% 884 9.3%
Cuyahoga Community College District Public 2-Year 1,181 74.6% 801 8.4%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 2,391 61.6% 774 8.2%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 1,988 51.7% 756 8.0%
Case Western Reserve University Private NFP 4-Year 1,832 55.1% 539 5.7%
University of Toledo Public 4-Year 1,760 50.3% 537 5.7%
Table 26: Healthcare & Human Services: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 51.3801 Registered Nursing/Registered Nurse Associate's degree 7,379 49.4% 56 1
2 44.0701 Social Work Associate's degree 1,572 10.5% 39 7
3 51.3901 Licensed Practical/Vocational Nurse Training Associate's degree 1,384 9.3% 33 1
4 51.3902 Nursing Assistant/Aide and Patient Care Assistant/Aide Certificate 1,176 7.9% 11 1
5 51.0904 Emergency Medical Technology/Technician (EMT Paramedic) Associate's degree 738 4.9% 17 2
6 51.0701 Health/Health Care Administration/Management Associate's degree 656 4.4% 21 1
7 51.1201 Medicine Doctor's or Professional 526 3.5% 6 15
8 51.0713 Medical Insurance Coding Specialist/Coder Associate's degree 524 3.5% 22 2
9 12.0409 Aesthetician/Esthetician and Skin Care Specialist Certificate 518 3.5% 13 1
10 51.0801 Medical/Clinical Assistant Associate's degree 460 3.1% 40 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 27: Healthcare & Human Services: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Hospitality, Events, & Tourism

Hospitality, Events, & Tourism includes accommodations, conferences and events, culinary and food services, and recreation and tourism. This cluster has among the lowest conversion rates of all 14 clusters: most occupational openings fall outside typical higher education pathways, filled instead through on-the-job training and experience-based progression. The portion of demand that is postsecondary aligned is nonetheless real, concentrated in culinary management, events coordination, and hospitality administration roles. As with other low-conversion clusters, the demand-supply ratio is less informative than the absolute gap for gauging where program investment would have the greatest impact.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Accommodations; Conferences & Events; Culinary & Food Services; Travel & Leisure
Adj. Graduates 852
Conversion Rate 5.0%
Annual Supply Gap 6,260
Proj. Annual Growth 191
Total Employment 218,795
Total Earnings $9.3B
Avg Earnings/Worker $42,600
D-S Ratio 8.341
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 28: Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Hospitality, Events, & Tourism. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 28: Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Hospitality, Events, & Tourism adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 29: Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 30: Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 705 37.0% 131 20.7%
Cuyahoga Community College District Public 2-Year 254 62.6% 104 16.3%
Cincinnati State Technical and Community College Public 2-Year 245 55.4% 83 13.1%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 868 60.2% 72 11.4%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,097 62.7% 63 10.0%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 921 51.0% 43 6.7%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 652 36.2% 41 6.5%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 725 53.8% 39 6.1%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 176 64.8% 37 5.8%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 281 70.3% 21 3.3%
Table 29: Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 52.1401 Marketing/Marketing Management, General Associate's degree 252 31.7% 43 2
2 52.0901 Hospitality Administration/Management, General Associate's degree 145 18.3% 6 3
3 12.0503 Culinary Arts/Chef Training Associate's degree 139 17.4% 10 3
4 09.0100 Communication, General Associate's degree 55 6.9% 15 2
5 12.0501 Baking and Pastry Arts/Baker/Pastry Chef Associate's degree 49 6.1% 5 2
6 09.0902 Public Relations/Image Management Associate's degree 45 5.6% 15 2
7 01.0605 Landscaping and Groundskeeping Associate's degree 42 5.3% 4 2
8 09.0909 Communication Management and Strategic Communications Bachelor's degree 28 3.5% 5 1
9 52.0905 Restaurant/Food Services Management Associate's degree 22 2.7% 4 2
10 31.0504 Sport and Fitness Administration/Management Associate's degree 20 2.5% 43 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 30: Hospitality, Events, & Tourism: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Management & Entrepreneurship

Management & Entrepreneurship covers business information management, entrepreneurship, human resources, operations management, and project management. Demand spans degree levels; bachelor’s programs dominate supply, but sub-baccalaureate credentials in operations and human resources represent an underdeveloped pipeline relative to employer demand. The combination of scale, earnings weight, and cross-sector relevance makes Management & Entrepreneurship a high-priority cluster for both program expansion and transfer pathway development.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Business Information Management; Entrepreneurship & Small Business; Leadership & Operations; Project Management; Regulation
Adj. Graduates 15,319
Conversion Rate 9.1%
Annual Supply Gap 13,380
Proj. Annual Growth 644
Total Employment 664,563
Total Earnings $57.1B
Avg Earnings/Worker $85,900
D-S Ratio 1.871
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 31: Management & Entrepreneurship: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Management & Entrepreneurship. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 31: Management & Entrepreneurship: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Management & Entrepreneurship adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 32: Management & Entrepreneurship: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Management & Entrepreneurship: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 33: Management & Entrepreneurship: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 8,224 31.7% 2,225 24.4%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 4,974 52.2% 1,748 19.2%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,797 61.2% 1,059 11.6%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,552 53.0% 936 10.3%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 1,775 58.4% 675 7.4%
Franklin University Private NFP 4-Year 1,441 57.8% 615 6.7%
Cleveland State University Public 4-Year 1,175 72.1% 610 6.7%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 2,043 39.7% 430 4.7%
Eastern Gateway Community College Public 2-Year 2,492 19.3% 424 4.7%
Youngstown State University Public 4-Year 835 62.8% 392 4.3%
Table 32: Management & Entrepreneurship: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 52.0201 Business Administration and Management, General Associate's degree 7,497 49.8% 55 13
2 52.0411 Customer Service Support/Call Center/Teleservice Operation Certificate 1,713 11.4% 4 1
3 42.0101 Psychology, General Associate's degree 1,620 10.8% 60 2
4 52.0801 Finance, General Associate's degree 1,084 7.2% 35 3
5 52.0101 Business/Commerce, General Associate's degree 850 5.6% 23 7
6 52.0701 Entrepreneurship/Entrepreneurial Studies Associate's degree 585 3.9% 16 3
7 09.0101 Speech Communication and Rhetoric Associate's degree 574 3.8% 29 2
8 52.1001 Human Resources Management/Personnel Administration, General Associate's degree 401 2.7% 22 7
9 52.0213 Organizational Leadership Bachelor's degree 397 2.6% 15 4
10 42.2704 Experimental Psychology Bachelor's degree 346 2.3% 5 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 33: Management & Entrepreneurship: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Marketing & Sales

Marketing & Sales includes e-commerce and digital marketing, market research and analytics, merchandising, and professional sales. Demand is concentrated at the bachelor’s level, though digital marketing and e-commerce roles increasingly draw candidates from shorter-term credentials and non-traditional pathways. Graduate supply from private institutions is relatively high compared to other clusters, reflecting the prominence of business programs at both private nonprofit and for-profit institutions. The market research and analytics Sub-Cluster, while smaller in volume, reflects growing employer demand for data-literate marketing professionals and may represent a targeted opportunity for applied analytics programs.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Market Research, Analytics, & Ethics; Marketing & Advertising; Retail & Customer Experience; Strategic Sales
Adj. Graduates 2,357
Conversion Rate 9.7%
Annual Supply Gap 9,407
Proj. Annual Growth 320
Total Employment 319,146
Total Earnings $21.6B
Avg Earnings/Worker $67,700
D-S Ratio 4.991
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 34: Marketing & Sales: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Marketing & Sales. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 34: Marketing & Sales: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Marketing & Sales adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 35: Marketing & Sales: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Marketing & Sales: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 36: Marketing & Sales: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 914 64.6% 306 18.6%
Kent State University at Kent Public 4-Year 915 59.5% 303 18.4%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 892 59.0% 224 13.6%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 770 49.6% 203 12.3%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 359 56.4% 140 8.5%
University of Toledo Public 4-Year 406 57.0% 109 6.6%
Miami University-Oxford Public 4-Year 451 37.5% 99 6.0%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 228 74.2% 98 6.0%
University of Dayton Private NFP 4-Year 295 58.6% 83 5.0%
Bowling Green State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 279 60.3% 81 4.9%
Table 35: Marketing & Sales: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 52.1401 Marketing/Marketing Management, General Associate's degree 1,535 65.9% 43 4
2 52.0201 Business Administration and Management, General Associate's degree 170 7.3% 55 1
3 52.1902 Fashion Merchandising Associate's degree 150 6.4% 4 1
4 50.0406 Commercial Photography Associate's degree 130 5.6% 3 1
5 30.7102 Business Analytics Associate's degree 125 5.4% 6 2
6 52.1804 Selling Skills and Sales Operations Associate's degree 76 3.3% 7 5
7 52.1801 Sales, Distribution, and Marketing Operations, General Associate's degree 56 2.4% 3 1
8 09.0903 Advertising Associate's degree 35 1.5% 4 1
9 52.0101 Business/Commerce, General Associate's degree 35 1.5% 23 1
10 52.1499 Marketing, Other Bachelor's degree 18 0.8% 5 2
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 36: Marketing & Sales: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Public Service & Safety

Public Service & Safety covers corrections and security, emergency services, government and public administration, law and legal services, and military and defense. Demand spans associate’s through bachelor’s and professional degree levels, reflecting the credential diversity of the occupations involved. Law and legal services Sub-Clusters exhibit some of the largest demand-supply ratios in the dataset at the doctoral/doctor’s level; these figures are best interpreted relative to the absolute gap rather than the ratio, as small graduate volumes in narrow specializations can produce extreme ratios that overstate the addressable shortage. Replacement demand is a larger driver of openings in this cluster than growth, consistent with the public sector employment patterns underlying most of its occupations.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Emergency Response; Judicial Systems; Local, State, & Federal Services; Military & National Security; Public Safety
Adj. Graduates 3,363
Conversion Rate 8.3%
Annual Supply Gap 8,850
Proj. Annual Growth 512
Total Employment 288,162
Total Earnings $22.4B
Avg Earnings/Worker $77,900
D-S Ratio 3.631
1 D-S ratio = annual demand ÷ adjusted graduate supply. This cluster has a conversion rate below 10%, indicating very limited higher-education pathways relative to total openings. The supply gap is the more reliable comparator.
Table 37: Public Service & Safety: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Public Service & Safety. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 37: Public Service & Safety: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Public Service & Safety adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 38: Public Service & Safety: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Public Service & Safety: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 39: Public Service & Safety: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 4,305 52.1% 401 15.9%
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 1,037 39.7% 323 12.8%
Clark State College Public 2-Year 445 80.6% 310 12.3%
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Public 4-Year 2,032 58.5% 309 12.2%
Eastern Gateway Community College Public 2-Year 1,870 23.0% 303 12.0%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 306 72.0% 197 7.8%
Cleveland State University Public 4-Year 1,081 70.1% 188 7.5%
University of Akron Main Campus Public 4-Year 759 61.7% 180 7.1%
Ohio University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 1,415 49.6% 170 6.7%
University of Toledo Public 4-Year 955 49.6% 143 5.6%
Table 38: Public Service & Safety: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 43.0107 Criminal Justice/Police Science Associate's degree 949 25.4% 26 4
2 22.0101 Law Doctor's or Professional 678 18.1% 9 5
3 43.0203 Fire Science/Fire-fighting Associate's degree 583 15.6% 8 3
4 43.0104 Criminal Justice/Safety Studies Associate's degree 548 14.6% 23 2
5 14.0801 Civil Engineering, General Bachelor's degree 207 5.5% 12 1
6 45.0603 Econometrics and Quantitative Economics Bachelor's degree 205 5.5% 12 2
7 03.0103 Environmental Studies Associate's degree 155 4.1% 16 1
8 03.0104 Environmental Science Associate's degree 149 4.0% 28 2
9 22.0302 Legal Assistant/Paralegal Associate's degree 139 3.7% 15 2
10 44.0701 Social Work Associate's degree 128 3.4% 39 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 39: Public Service & Safety: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC

Supply Chain & Transportation

Supply Chain & Transportation includes air and space transportation, distribution and warehousing, logistics management, maritime transportation, rail transportation, and trucking and ground transportation. The cluster’s conversion rate is approximately 16%, meaning that postsecondary pathways cover a meaningful but not dominant share of the cluster’s total occupational openings. The postsecondary-relevant portion of the cluster is concentrated in logistics management and supply chain analytics, roles where program development at both the associate’s and bachelor’s levels represents the most tractable near-term opportunity for closing the credential gap. The remainder of cluster demand is filled through driver and operator pathways that fall outside the framework’s higher-education scope.

Career Cluster Summary
Metric Value
Sub-Clusters Air & Space Transportation; Ground & Rail Transportation; Maintenance & Repair; Marine Transportation; Planning & Logistics; Purchasing & Warehousing
Adj. Graduates 1,521
Conversion Rate 15.9%
Annual Supply Gap 4,863
Proj. Annual Growth 243
Total Employment 282,533
Total Earnings $17.8B
Avg Earnings/Worker $62,800
D-S Ratio 4.20
Table 40: Supply Chain & Transportation: Career Cluster Summary. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Horizontal bar chart of the annual supply gap for each Sub-Cluster in Supply Chain & Transportation. Shortages appear as red bars extending right of zero and surpluses as gray bars extending left; each bar is labeled with its value.
Figure 40: Supply Chain & Transportation: Annual Supply Gap by Sub-Cluster. Annual openings minus adjusted graduates; red bars are shortages, gray bars are surpluses. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Donut chart showing the share of Supply Chain & Transportation adjusted graduates produced by each institution type, with each slice labeled by institution type and percentage.
Figure 41: Supply Chain & Transportation: Adjusted Graduate Distribution by Institution Type. Source: IPEDS, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Supply Chain & Transportation: Two-panel figure by education level. Left, stacked bars show adjusted graduates with the supply gap stacked on top, or extending below zero where graduates exceed openings. Right, bars show the demand-supply ratio at each level, with a dashed reference line at 1.0 marking balance.
Figure 42: Supply Chain & Transportation: Supply Gap by Education Level. Source: IPEDS, Ohio LMI, PSEO | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Ranked by annual adjusted graduates contributed to this career cluster
Institution Type Total Grads (Raw) Stay-in-State Rate Adj. Graduates % of Cluster Supply
Sinclair Community College Public 2-Year 1,509 49.3% 405 31.8%
Stark State College Public 2-Year 344 73.9% 235 18.4%
Ohio Technical College Private FP 2-Year 220 74.1% 159 12.4%
Columbus State Community College Public 2-Year 480 74.3% 114 9.0%
Cuyahoga Community College District Public 2-Year 166 73.1% 104 8.2%
Ohio State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 298 46.9% 78 6.1%
Washington State Community College Public 2-Year 82 73.3% 60 4.7%
Bowling Green State University-Main Campus Public 4-Year 128 61.8% 46 3.6%
University of Toledo Public 4-Year 212 58.9% 39 3.1%
University of Northwestern Ohio Private NFP 4-Year 158 60.1% 33 2.6%
Table 41: Supply Chain & Transportation: Top Producing Institutions. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC
Aggregated across all degree levels; primary degree level shown
# CIP Code Program Primary Level Adj. Graduates1 % of Cluster Supply # Institutions # SOCs Served
1 47.0604 Automobile/Automotive Mechanics Technology/Technician Associate's degree 528 39.8% 8 3
2 52.0203 Logistics, Materials, and Supply Chain Management Associate's degree 226 17.0% 11 2
3 51.0810 Emergency Care Attendant (EMT Ambulance) Certificate 139 10.5% 3 1
4 15.0803 Automotive Engineering Technology/Technician Associate's degree 124 9.4% 5 2
5 52.0201 Business Administration and Management, General Bachelor's degree 80 6.0% 55 1
6 52.0205 Operations Management and Supervision Bachelor's degree 63 4.8% 10 1
7 49.0205 Truck and Bus Driver/Commercial Vehicle Operator and Instructor Certificate 48 3.6% 3 4
8 47.0613 Medium/Heavy Vehicle and Truck Technology/Technician Associate's degree 42 3.2% 2 2
9 47.0608 Aircraft Powerplant Technology/Technician Associate's degree 40 3.1% 3 1
10 47.0607 Airframe Mechanics and Aircraft Maintenance Technology/Technician Associate's degree 36 2.7% 3 1
1 Adjusted graduates reflect stay-in-state rate × CIP-SOC crosswalk weight; summed across SOCs within cluster.
Table 42: Supply Chain & Transportation: Top Producing Programs. Source: IPEDS, PSEO, Advance CTE | Ohio State CHRR/OERC